Assignment title: Information
CIS8100 Assignment 2
Technical Report Assignment
You will create a technical report that compares two desktop productivity applications
and makes a recommendation based on functionality and ease of use only. This is
different from a research report in that you will investigate the functionality and ease of
use of two different desktop productivity applications and make a recommendation. In
particular, do not consider the cost of the product in your recommendation decision. The
true cost is complex and must consider support, implementation, training and other
factors. Financial considerations are out of scope for this report.
Assignment Requirements
Here's the scenario: Your boss has asked you to compare 2 desktop productivity
applications that are being considered for adoption by your company. Your boss has
asked you to investigate these applications, compare their features only, and make a
clear recommendation for adoption.
Audience: (technical) IT manager
You will choose 2 desktop productivity applications of the same category, and compare
their functionality and ease of use. The applications are suitable for a business setting.
You will write a technical report, including executive summary, and your
recommendation for adoption. You can choose from the Microsoft Office, Open Office,
or LibreOffice applications. You can also compare one of these to the appropriate Apple
products, but be careful not to make it a Windows vs. Apple OS comparison as well.
Here are some examples of products you may choose to compare:
• 2 of MS Word, Open Office Writer or LibreOffice Writer
• 2 of MS Excel, Open Office Calc, or LibreOffice Calc
• 2 of MS PowerPoint, Open Office Presentation, or LibreOffice Impress
• 2 of MS Access, Open Office Base, LibreOffice Base
• Photoshop vs. Gimp
• MS Outlook vs. Thunderbird
• comparisons approved by your professor
You may NOT compare:
• Web browsers
• Chat, file sharing software, games, mobile apps
• Operating Systems (MS Windows vs Linux)
• applications that are too small for comparison (Paint, Notepad)Report Requirements:
• 1,200- 1,500 words (with images, the report should be approximately 8 - 10
pages)
• Format your document such that headings are obvious (bold, larger font)
• Use 1" margins, and page numbers on the bottom of each page
• Create an appropriate title page (do not put the page number on this page)
• Include the following sections, in this order:
o Introduction
Introduce the two products that will be compared including the
category of software and brief explanation of the productivity tasks
that can be accomplished with the software.
o Executive Summary
Briefly summarize your discussion, and recommendation. Do not
re-state your conclusion. This section should stand on its own, and
can be removed from the full report, to give to an "executive".
Include a summary of the discussion and recommendation. This
should be 1 page or less and you should write it after you've written
the rest of the report.
o Discussion
Compare the functionality and ease of use of the two
products. Since these products may be robust and complex, focus
on 3 - 5 different tasks and compare the method used to perform
these tasks in each product. Find the strengths of each application
and compare those features. Be sure to include visuals (Figures)
showing screen captures of each product and its method for
performing the task. Label parts of the visuals where appropriate for
the discussion. This is not a step-by-step tutorial. This should be an
explanation of how each task is accomplished, in general,
contrasting the different methods for each application. When
comparing usability, use a concrete measurement such as number
of clicks. For instance, one application may have a button available
to perform a task, where the other has the task buried in a menu
system 3 layers deep.
This should be the bulk of your report, approximately 800 words
o Conclusion
Summarize your findings. Briefly, what were the pros and cons of
each application with respect to each other. Compare them. Do not
just list the features of each application.
Recommend one product and state your reasons why you
recommend this one, taking into consideration only functionality
and ease of use. Do not consider cost, or platform.
o References (if appropriate)
All work in this document should be your original work, and as such
you may not need to use any other references. If you do some
research and use this information in your report, you must cite thesource. For instance, if you make statements about the sales of the
product, its popularity or other factual information, you must cite or
footnote the reference and include it in a References section.
Technical Report Presentation:
You will present your report findings to the class in a 3 minute presentation. You are
encouraged to use a PowerPoint presentation. Displaying your report to the audience is
distracting and leaves the impression that the presentation is unprepared.
Marking Scheme:
/15 Spelling/Grammar
/15 Sentence structure/flow
/5 Introduction
/5 Executive
Summary
/35 Discussion
/5 Conclusion
/5 Logic (conclusions relate
to discussion)
/10 Visuals
/5 Formatting
/100 Total
Submitting the Assignment
Ensure that your assignment is a single Word document (.doc or .docx). Please submit
your assignment file via eLearn. Late assignments will receive a grade of 0.