Identifies the paper under review (1)

ii) States the purpose of the student essay (2)

iii) Is refined and clearly stated (1)

iv) Provides an overview of the papers being discussed (1)

Contains appropriate material (2)

ii) Presents a well-structured discussion (2)

iii) Uses material from other authors (3)

iv) Summarises and discusses the content of the article(s) (4)

v) Identifies and discusses the article’s conclusions (4) 

Citations are indicated correctly (Harvard) (2)

ii) Grammatical expression is satisfactory (3)