! " #
$%
&'' (
)*+,-
,
,
./ 0-
!
! !1
*'+2-
*+ $1
&* 3+* 0++ + -
.
* * 14 1 . -
*'2+0
$1
&* -*- 5
*'
1 --
!
6 0
-0
1
&,* (
)0 50'3
0
7 6 % 8 -3
*
3
3 9
&'5 (
)0
0 35
,
: 1
1
7
; 1 *5++/
1 4/ <
4
"
$% ;
1 *5++
/
=
*55-
> *55, *55+
22
;
? @
< A/
/B /
/ /
.
"/
.<
2,0 2
-3032+ (/ )
*/ B! / /
B! / ./ < A/
:1*5
/-'3
,-+/'
'B *
3'-,+
.<2
2,0 2
-3032+
1 4
*
@*0 :
; 1
9
:A .
=
4
/
2/
"
"
1 "4
1
4 "4
*/* : ? *
*/ ?
*/0 ? 0
*/' ? -
*/- ? 3
*/, ?
? 4 5
*/3 ? **
! "
/* . *,
/ ; *,
/0 7 6!
/' C 6!
/- >4 0
/, D 3
/3 4 +
/+ +
# $$
% #&
0/* . 0
0/ 0
0/0 ? 00
40/' ? 4 03
0/- 05
0/, > 05
0/3 > '0
' (!
) ''
'/* ; ''
'/ E ',
'/0 . '5
'/' E 2 -
'/- E -
'/, E -0
'/3 : D (:E!) -0
'/+ 2 (>) :E! --
* +
*,
! "
-/* 4 -+
-/ 4 (.1) ,
-/0 ,
-/' 4 ,0
-/- ,-
-/, 2 ,,
-/3 . ,3
-/+ 4 ,+
-/5 .1 ,5
-/*
! 4 30
-/** 4 3-
-/* 4 +
" -
,"
,/* = ? +,
,/ +3
,/0 ? ++
,/' = +5
,/- = 5*
,/, ;
5
,/3 : 50
,/+ 1 4 ? 5+
,/5 > *
4 .
&*
3/* *
-
3/ *
3
3/0 . *
5
3/' D **
3/-
D ? **5
3/, * *
3/3 . * 0
3/+ > * '
, % .
#
+/* * 3
+/ ? * 3
+/0 ? * +
+/' $ * 5
+/- *0*
+/, *0'
+/3 *0-
/
#.
5/* *03
5/ *0+
5/0 < *05
5/' $ *'-
5/- > *',
5/, *',
5/3 *'3
& 0
!
1! *"
*
/* ? *-,
*
/ 4 *-3
*
/0 : 4 4 *-5
*
/' > ? 4 *,*
*
/- 6 *,0
*
/, 4 D *,'
*
/3 1 61 *,,
*
/+ " 61 *,3
*
/5 *3
4 )
.'
$
**/* " *3'
**/ = *3-
**/0 *33
**/' *35
**/- ?
? 4 *+
**/, *+
**/3 ? *+,
**/+ > *50
**/5 : *5'
**/*
!
*
**/**
2
'
) 2 ! &"
$
* /* :
,
* /
3
* /0
+
* /' 2D **
* /- *
* /, : 4 *0
* /3 : 4 *'
* /+ : *-
#
2
3! !
#
*0/*
*0/
0
*0/0 -
*0/' . " ? 0*
*0/- : 0
*0/,
4 00
*0/3 " 0'
*0/+ 0,
' 2
#,
%&
*'/* > 0+
*'/ $ 05
*'/0 7 '*
*'/' : '0
4 *'/- ! ? '3
*'/, ;
--
*'/3 -3
*'/+ . -5
*'/5 ; ,*
* !$$)
"'
*-/* ,'
*-/ 4 ,-
*-/0 ,,
*-/' : ,5
*-/- 7 2 3
*-/, : ? 4 3-
*-/3 ? 4 33
*-/+ +*
*-/5 : +-
*-/*
+3
"
45 !$$)
/&
*,/* 5
*,/ : 5*
*,/0 5
*,/'
5+
*,/- ! 0
*,/, 0
*,/3 0
0
*,/+ 0
-
.
+ -
+ !6
7
+
$ #&.
*3/* 0
3
*3/ ; ? 0
+
*3/0 0
5
*3/' 0**
*3/- ? 0**
*3/, 0*0
*3/3 " 0*'
*3/+ ? 0*-
*3/5 ?
0*3
*3/*
> ? 0*3
"*3/** 0*5
*3/* 14 4 ? 0 *
*3/*0 : =. 0 0
*3/*' : 4
4 0 0
*3/*- =. $% 0 -
*3/*, 0 ,
*3/*3 0 +
*3/*+ =
F 4 0 5
, $ 8 $
!
###
*+/* ! 2 ? 000
*+/ . ? 00-
*+/0 ? 00,
*+/' $% 2 ? 003
*+/- $ 00+
*+/, .4 005
/
2+$
!
#'
! "
*5/* 7 4 G 0'*
*5/ : 4 0'-
*5/0 = 0',
*5/' 1 0'3
*5/-
2 4 0'5
*5/, 0-*
*5/3 : 0-
*5/+ 0-0
*5/5 0--
&
-!! 8
#*.
/* : 0-+
/ 9 ? 0-5
/0 ? F 0,
1 " 5 0,'
." 03
" 8
. ?
4 ?
? 4
/ . 4
?
24
= 4
*5+
( = / >
.D
! = C! *5+
)/
*55-
4 4
/ 1 ? ! ,
35
$%2
1 ? !
#
? / :
4 4
4 (;) ? /
!
? / 4 4
4
2 / :
4
?
/ : 4
4
4
? 2
4
*55-/
:
/ :
4
4
4 / ?
? 4 ? 4 ?
? 4
4 / :
" 4
4 ? / :
? ? /
< ? ? 2
! !1 ! 4 "
/ :
? 2
? $% 4 /
< A/
" 9
8
6!
: 8
! =. !1!
? ! 4
$4 / 1 $4
? / C 2
? 4
/ C
/
C ; = /
2
5; ; !1 ? !2
4 $4 /
? ! $!.:/
!
; ! ; 4 D
/
7 9 *
" 4
/
< $! ? ? 2
C ?
4
4
/ C
? 2
2 ? / C
4
?
! 4 4
$!.:/ ! ; ? !
/
8 +
! 4 2
$4 / C
4
" 4 / C ?
> .!. H ! IJ
;:>J ;:.J $ ' -
= / C 4 ; 4
$4 / C
4 /
) 1 ! ; !. !1! !.E1
9
; 4 $!.:/ 1
44
?
$% 4 /
=
) ! 1.1
!2
4 $4 / 1
< $4
= 1
C 7 $4 / C 4
2
? / C
2
&
/
%
() ! !. !.7!
4 6
4 $!.:/ C 4 "
C %
1
$%/ C " 4
$% : : 4
!
. 4 / C
" 4 4 4
? /
2 +
>
!1 . 1.1
"
A 0
/ C "
4
/ C
!
! ! K 9 / C
/ ;4
6 $!.: 6 =
$4 /
"4
%;
. 2
4
; ; ; : ! ! . 6 / .
! C 4
! ! % ! ! ;4 7 / .
: 4 7 J ; % L .!
5/
: "
! "
4
/ . 4
4 4 / <4
/
< A/
"49
8 66+
1 1
17 1
1; 1 ;4
1;> 1 4
1 ; 1 ;4
1! 1 ? !
1 (
)
7
7
; F F4
F F
FF
: FF F
F
: FF F
E D
: F F
> 2
>: F F
: F F
1 F
.. . . (:")
; 4
. "
6 4
; ! ;F
F F
; : ;F
F F
;!= ;
; ;
;:> ; 4 : >
;=1 ;
; .; ; . ;4
"4;=! ;
;! ; "
;:. ; : .
>; > ;4
9; " 9 ;
. .
.1 4
. .4
. 4
! 4
F F
. F F F
E. 4 D "
>
$ $
61 4
= : =F
FF F
=.;. =M M . .M
()
9$. 9
C! C !? I 4
.= . =
.: . ?
.>> .
!; ! ;
<1 < 4 1
<9 <24
<.= <
<6 < 4
; ;4
F
? "
>: 4 >4 :D
=. 4 4
. F F
.!
!. ? ! .
>
D
E1 E
1
4 "4E E
E=; E
>$= >44
1
!
. "
6 ? 4
6 4
:! : 4
:< :
:E! : D
:$ : 4
$9= $ 9
61 6
6 6
6! 6
6 6
6> 6 4
7 7
7!9 7 ! 9
7:1 7
7: 7
"4 1
4
!
"
#
$
$
$
%
&
"
'
$
( )
)
(
(
*
+
(
#
(
(
&
"
,
-
-
-
-
(
$
-
$
$
&
"
#
) .#)/ 0+$
&
"
01 $
#
&
.
/ "
2 *
#
3
+
) .3+4567/
&
"
%
,
-
-
-
-
-
(
#)
&
"
01 $
#
&
"
3
+
) .3+ 4567/ &
"
(
)
#
#
8
)
#
9
(
*
$
.'77:/
%
''
*
(
( +
%
''
(
#
; *
#
(
$ %
''
(
$
%
&
"
(
)
9
"
& "
<
$
)
(
=
#
#
:
%
!
,
)
>
%
''
+
>
(
=
>
%
''
0
(
%
(
4 *
#
( (
%
''
%
''
#
$
(
$
%
''
)
#
&
" %
'2
%
.
/
? $
(
@
? 3
? !
@
$
#
#
6
A *
#
)
0
$
+
(
.
/
.
/
)
(
%
'8
(
!
(
Possible
added
value
Pre-project Project Operation
Decide
what you
want
Design
and
construction
Earning
Opportunity
Cost
of late
change
#
#
7
#
$
"
#
%
';
(
-
&
"
.
3
'778/
'5 *
#
(
)
$
!
"
)
(
B
(
C
#
(
#
#
''
$
(
&
"
$
>
-
(
$
!
9
+
C
9 $
*
'2 *
#
#
(
)
&
"
9
)
)
(
(
+
>
)
!
)
(
)
(
#
#
'8%
+
!
+
(
#
)
&
"
(
$
(
!
!
!
"
#
"
+
+
)
#
"
'; *
#
(
$
(
$
$
!
)
9
"
+C .'77:/
# ' .* BD +/
3 + (
$# .'77A/ $
%
; $ #
!
3+ 4567 .2555/ &
# 3
+
)
?
# .'776/ #
2
?
"! % .'774/ '
(
2 #
C
?
#) .2555/ &
# $
%
#
) 0
>
#$
+ BD .'77A/ #
3 +
?
= .2555/ '
)$ # 8
?
0B)> .'77;/ #
" * (
0 B )
>
9 B
E
+C #$ 3
B? .'7A7/
2
?
#
#
':
!"#$ %
!"&$
!"'$
!"($
"#
"#
(
) '
!*++,$-
"
*, !"#$
!"&$
"&
% %
!"'$
"'
%
!"($
!".$
"(
"(
"#
%
/
0* "& "'
1
"'
%
"#
"#
!
$ "#
"
!
$
"
# *2 "
Value management
Value planning Value engineering Value review
Pre-investment phase
Unbudgeted Budgeted projects
Investment phase
Implementation Operation End of assets
Concept Pre-feasibility Feasibility Appraisal Procurement
training Operation Decommissioning Close out
Define
project
Define project
approach
Develop
approach/design
Feedback
Develop
detailed
approach
Procurement
and training
Handover/post project evaluation
Next project
Strategy: Corporate, Business & Project
*3 '
&
#
%
4
5
%
/
!
$
6
(
%
!$
!1#
)
7 &
*++,$
%
!*$
-
%
!0$
-
%
!8$ 9
-
!:$ '
-
!;$ < -
!,$ .
!2$ %-
(
=
%
%
"
# *+ - !
$
!
$
'
-
>
-
!
$
!
$
%
. !
$
.
?
(
-
@
@
@
&
% %
(
"#
9
-
% 5
0A '
&
#
%
%
%
%
5
%
%
%
%
"#
!
$ "#
1
%
"#
%
%
%
=
"# %
!
%
$
-
@
@
%
@
%
@
@
"#
%
"
# 0* % "#
%
%
!1#
*++,$
"#
!>
#' *++;$
"#
-
% @
%
@
@
@
%
%
!
$
"& "'
5
"#
%
%
1
"#
9
!&'&$
-
@
@
00 '
&
#
@
%
'
%
% "#
-
%
@
5
@
! $
@
!
$
% @
5
@
5
@
5
! "#
(
"#
!*$ B %
!0$ '
%
"
# 08
.
%
"#
!8$
!:$ (
!
5 5
$
!;$
!,$ )
!*$ )
!0$ (
!8$ (
!:$ (
!;$ (
!$
!,$ (
!2$ (
5
5
%
!*$ .
%
!0$ '
!8$ '
!:$ <
!;$ &
!*$ (
5
0: '
&
# !0$ (
!8$
<
5 *AC8AD
% "'
!*$ .
!0$ ) % % %
!8$ . %
!:$ '
!;$ <
!,$ (
%
!*$ (
%
!0$ )
%
!8$
"'
"&
6
%
= !
$4
= 4
= 4
1
4
=
4
= 4
"
# 0;
!*$ &
"#
!0$ /
!8$ (
!:$ (
!;$ (
!
$
!*$ &
"#
!0$ (
!8$ (
!:$ 9
%
!;$ ) %
%
!*$ (
!0$
!8$ (
%
!:$ (
5
!;$ ( %
%
!,$ (
0, '
&
# &
"#
%
%
1
4
=
4
=
4
<
4
4
/
%
(
%
-
@
@
@
$ %
&
"#
-
&
/(9
!
$
%
% 5
%
"
# 02' (
#
&
"#
&
<
%
&
%
<
7
'
&
&
%
)
#
&
%
&
&
) *
%
"#
%
%
-
%
@
@
03 '
&
#
"#
-
@
@
@
@
@
@
%
@
"#
"
1#
!*++,$ )
7 &
?
> ;:
1#9 B
) '
!*++,$
B
>
6. #' =) !*++;$
# B
)
E> ?
9< !*++,$
! ).( B
= ( !*++:$ " ) F 1 B
"
# 0+
!
"#
$ %
&
'
(
")PROJECT APPRAISAL PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION OPERATION OF THE ASSET
INITIATION
PROJECT ACCOUNT BALANCE
MONEY
TIME
DEFINITION
CONCEPT
DESIGN
CONSTRUCTION
COM
Regulatory approval
Planning
approval
Contract award
– +
SANCTION
COMPLETION
Cost Cost and benefit
*
+ "#
'
$
!
"#%
, -
( -
(
-
(
!
"#
&
$#%
(
$.%
". /
+
$"%
/
0
$1%
+
$2%
3
/
#)4
3
5 6)4
!
".
*
+ ""Possibilities of
reducing cost
Percentage cost
Investment
decision
Accumulated amount
of investment
Decision steps
APPRAISAL IMPLEMENTATION
Preplanning Planning Design and construct
equipment
Installation of equipment Time
7
"1 /
+
8
'
5
8
'
,
9
,
.)).
(
:.2
#)4
*
+ "2
(
(
+
;
'
,
,
'
<
,
,
,
"= /
+
,
/
<
,
!
<
!
$
%
6 #)
")
/
>
*
+ ":
0 8
+
/
8
/
5
8
!
8
3
8
!
"6 /
+! "
+
*
?
,
7
'
0
/
!
"#8"1
#
'
<
,
$
%,
,
*
+ "@$%
*
;
9 '
0
;
9
$% ?
*
;
?
?
?A+
+
0
1) /
+$% !
*
;
$
%
B
B
<
/
;
0
0
<
$% *
*
;
;
+
<
; 0
*
+ 1#*
*
'
,
,
,
$
%
'
-
(
,
,
,
*
C
<
*
'
,
<
,
,
,
+
1. /
+
0
& '
*
3
DE
*
9
0 .)
+
/F $#@66%
D
B
F7
$#@@.%
B
>
9F $#@@6%
C >
?
*
+ 1"
!
"
#
"
"
#
$
%
!
% #
&
! '()*
++
,
"
-.
-(.
"
-" .
*
-
.
/
/
/
/
/
(
#
"
$
#
" %
01
2$3435
4
$
6
$6
5557 55+ 84 " +
$6 555
"
#
&
&9: 555 "
#
6
,
+3
/
2
"
*
!
/
% #
/
"
#
%
#
$6 555
(
;
;
,
,
#
,
,
(
#
(
<
%
"
$
$
+= &
,
"
*
!
%
%
&!
!
% (%
;
%
(
#
% "
';
(
)
+
(
#
)
"
%
"
+:
)
)
"
%
%
" ;
,
+4
%
"
%
"
"
+8 &
,
!
"
/
"
"
#
#
!
- .
-
.
-
.
!
#
*
>
/
!
/
/
% /
"
%
,
+
$
%
"
*
% %
%
#
(
#
%
"
*
% #
%
#
"
*
/
/
/
/
/
?
%
" )
"
!
"
"
"
35 &
,
%
!
6
"
,
*
!
*
#
-
. " *
%
#
&!
&!
#
%
,
3
&!
!
!
6 %
#
@
#
"
!
#
A "
%
"
*
/
!
"
>
$ %
"
%
#
#
#
$
"
3: &
,
!
# "
!
"
/
!
%
%
0
#
$
2$ 3435 ,
5: *
/
/
%
/
!
/
%
/
"
%
% "
%
& '
(
"
-" .
*
,
3B
%
"
"
#
%
+B "
"
"
*
)
/
/
/
"
/
/
"
" "
*
/
/
"
3+ &
,
/
/
%
/
% /
/
!
#
#
C
%
*
/
%
/
%/
/
/
) *
" '* +(
"
85
5
!
#
"
2,@
<
D
2,@*
#
" *
5E
,
33 $
2,@*
" *
(
2,@*
!
" *
!
2 2,@ "
#
2,@*
#
" *
@
2,@*
" *
2,@*
" *
#
" 2,@
" 2,@
9
2
# " #
( (
" &
*
@
*
(
(
?
,
(
#
!
@
- .
;
@%
<
$ 6
(
@ $
"
3= &
,
#
" 2,@ *
F
#
"
%
AG - 8 .
& H 9 $
G
2$3435 - 84.
2
$
G
2$= +B - :.
2
$
G
( #"
(A -&
. - +.
1 , 9 I
%
<
(
A - B.
!
" 9 2
G
< "
(
0 ,
D 9 +=
!
< $6 G
$6 555 - 84.
6
>
$
>#
D
$6 555= - 4. #
6
>
$
> D
6% A$ - 8 .
<
,
6!
,
34
!"#
$
!"
! %# &
'
( )
(
*
+ *
,-
*
*
%
#
# $
+
!
* .
%
$
.
!*
$
/
$
$
*
%
$
*
!
,0!
!
!"#
*
!"
!"
+
!%#
+
$
*
$
*
$
+
$
!%
!"
$
1 , 2 $
!"
!"
$
*
*
34 ! 5
%
+
$
*
*
$
* !"
*
$
!
$
!%
1
!"
!
" #
!
!
32
$
!"
$
!"
% !" 6
!" 1 *
!"
!" !%
+
$ * !"
$
%
$
!"
$
!"
*
$
*
!"
$
*
7
!" !"
+
.
!"
38 ! 5
$
!"
9%" 20:4 $
; "
<
20-, !"
! ;
"
! ;
;
& '
) $
& <
20--
$ &
+ !"
$
!"
6
+
* +
*
8244
2=,4
*
$ !"
*
*
!
3=
+
*
+
!
"
#
$
+
+
*
++)
9>
!"
*
5
9>) &
&
&&##
7
+ " &
+#
!"
3? ! 5
$ 9% @
!
5 " @!5"# ;
!
A
'
) %
!"
$
+
#
#
#
$
*
+
B
*
!"
$
+ * $
+
"
+
+
*
$
+
$
+ +
C
/
*
!
3, ;
+
"
*
*
%
*
$
!"
7
"
;
)
* *
*
$
!%
$
+
!%
$
!"
C
/ +
*
!" D
$
*
!%
!"
#$
$ *
33 ! 5
9
*
!"
$
* %
*
*
$
$
*
$
1 *
+
$
$
$
"
% #
1
$
$
$
!
3:&
+
1 *
'
)
+
E
+
%
&
$ !%
$ 6
*
$
6
*
"
' ) !
'
)
1
"
*
"
$
$
)
$
3- ! 5
$
!%
$
"
$
*
' (
)
.
+ !%
+ $
"
!% !" '
) $
+
+
*
;+
!"
;+
*#
%
;+
*
1
+
"
$
!%
% & $ +
!
30 & $
*
1
*
+)
'! & "
*
$
(
& $ +
+
+ +
$
# "
(
$
*
.
E
+
$
$
(
+
:4 ! 5
$
$
*
%
+
9
!"
"
*
#
$
+ $
2# &
1
8# !
$
) #
42 4
# 2
# $
+
* '*)
=# &
+ $ & "
?# $
*
!A#
!A ) =
2
&) ,2
&
) #
) #
!
:2 ,# &
!A
$
.
' ) *
$
!A
+
.
+
"
*
1
$
*
+
* +
* $
*
F
*
/
20:2# 9% D
%
$
* + /
* 244
(
* --
*
"
*
+
+
*
+
* 1
*
+
B
/
)
:8 ! 5
(
$
/
*
*
2 24 *
$
F
!" 20-4
$
$
*
*
"
*
+
!"
*
# #
)
!
+
9
$
!"
$
'
) ')
$
*
+
$
&
+
$
!
:=
$
+
$
*
7
#
+
"
*
!"
"
"
*
"
!"
.
!"
!"
C
"
!%
" !"
$
!%
*
24G
!"
,4G $
!%
:? ! 5
&
+
6
!%# ' )
#
1
; " *
6
=+ 2 4 ,8
+
E
$
6
; "
=+ 2 4 ,=
#
$
+
6
$
*
' )
7
!
:,
$
+
@
)
'
()H .
!
!
$
+
+ 5
$
1
*
*
+
%
*
$
$
*
$
'
( )
6
:3 ! 5
*
$; #
*
E
+
1 *
+
$
1
+
+
6 *
(
+
+
+ $
*
* +
&
' ) ' )
$
&
$
* #
1 *
(
%
(
!
::E
+
$
" *
,
$
$
1 *
E
+
"
+
+
,
$
' )
+ $ +
+
+
1 *
5
*
$
+ '
+)
$
*
$
E
:- ! 5
$
$
*
$
%
B +
+
$
$
+
$
+
+ $
+
'
) 7$5#
'
) 7$"#
$
$
!"
!%
!"
!
:0 6
$
+ !"
$
+
$
$
!
+
"
!"
!"
E !"
'
)
! %
7 !"
+
! %
+
)
+
# " ! %
)
)
) ! %
!% $ ! %
2008 % + --./0
-4 ! 5
$ 200?
% ::,4 2003
!@ %.
2? 442 %. 2? 444
!"
! % E
! %
$
! %
$ %. 2? 442
6
/ +
! %
$
%. 2? 442
! %
1 , 8
! %
!
$
! %
"
+ +
+ $
!
-2
+
)
*
*
$
)
%. 2? 442
$
*
#
"
%. 2? 442
#
$ ! % %. 2? 442#
-8 ! 5
$
)
$
"
$
)
7
1
*
'1 ! 2
!
./3
! 45
)
.
$
#
"
! %
+
$
*
$
! %
$
.
) ! % $
!
-=
$
I
$
1
" +
! %
$ ! %
5
)
"
*
%. 2? 442 7
*
$ ! %
$
+
! %
-? ! 5
+)
/
/ ;
+ 1 ! E
< I 20:2# "
9% D
% ;
3?,
&
9%"
#
E E < > " 2000# #6 47 ///0 #
)
D E
@ J +
E & 2008#
8 ! 8 /
%. 2003# #6 47 //40
9
)
. ( % ( D
I E I D 200-# #6 47 //40 #
,
& E
.*
$ I > 5 &
200?#
#
E 7 E
E
7 5 ! # 20--#
#
9 E
/
7 < $ 2002# :
9
E %. /
7 ; 200,#
#
"!
/
!*
!
-,
!
"
"
"
"#
#
"
"
$
" "
"
$
#
$
"
$
%
#
"
"
&'
%
#
$
(
') "
*
$
+
!
"
& +, "
"
-!
.
(
)
,
/
(
&0
1
2
3
*
*
. (
"
$
,)
" 1 4
5
"
!
"
#
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
$
6
"
"
"
"
"
78
)9&1:
"
;
#
#!
"
!
"
"
"
&& -
(
"
%
!
$
!
/
<
"
=
"
$
"
7): /
7/>:
7,: 8 #
71: %#
#
72: /
7 : <
7': <
70: <
7&: <
<
!
8
"
? "
!
"
"
.
@
;
+
;
(
&9$
"
$
"
$
!
<
!
#
"
$
$
%
!
(
? "#
#
!
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
$
$
"
"
<
"
"
$
"
"
%"
7)99&:
A
/>
6 $
"
!
3
"
!
$
A
BB
6
3
9 -
"
3
-
6
6
%
"
#
%
!
!
"
"
-!
"
!
BB
BB
-
"
7C (:
78(: "
<
"
!
BB
5
$
#
A
6 A
6
(
!
"
#
+#
$
"
*
$
" 0 4
!
$
A
6
!
(
5
, 2, $
!
(
9)
? "
!
/ -
$
"
#
"
#
"
$
"
$
B
@
B
"
!
!
.
#
@
"
!
@
D
@
"
" " "
<
#
"
@ "
" "
6
#
@
#
" "
"
@
"
$
$
"
"
#
9, -
$
" "
!
7CC:
78>:
"
D
"
!
"
@
7
"
:
;
7
8>
# "
:
E
+
"
#
(
"
)@)
"
"
# "
C
"
$
6
!
#
!"
$
$
"
$
"
$
"
(
91
<
"
"
$
"
E
"
"
E
$
"
#
"
%
$
"
$
"
"
"
"
$
"
$
"
"
C
F C
G D
"
D
!
<
@
#
), 4
#
) 4
92 -
#
) 4
#
), 4
" ) 4
%
"
6
"
#
"
"
<
<
"
<
$
3
"
$
"
%
"
"
BB
BB
#
#
"
$
#
<
@
"
;
#
"
(
9
;
#
"
;
;
<
@
$
"
"
!
"
$
"
"
$
"
!
" "
"
"
@
"
;
+ #
;
"
;
"
;
-!
!
"
9' -
"
# 3
"
;
!
$
!
!
$
+
!
!
$
!
!
!
!
"
"
7
:
!
7
#
:
/
!
#
(
* 7(*:
-
. C
3
7-.C3:
-
. 7-.:
#
6
$
6
!
(
"
#
/
"
-
<
$
? "
D
"
#
(
90# $ %"
$
#
!
"
@
+
!
7
:;
7
:
7
#
:
7
!
" " :
$
#
"
!
$
"
!
"
#
"
#
!
$
-. "
,
+
)2
"
,
# "
D
" " "
$
#
$
"
"
E
!
"
@
6
#
3 C
"
#
!
H)
!
"
9& -
!
#
"
"
I "I
I
7.%%$
:
#
"
$
.%%$
#
<
#
"
"
(
? "
;
"
%
"
#
#
#
"
"
$
$
@
"
"
#
"
;
"
"
;
"
;
"
!
!
#
(
99
!
"
"
& '(
$
"
D
"
<
"
"
"
"
.
(
"
#
!
" (#
#
$
"
(
@
7
:
;
# "
#
;
+
!
;
#
!
;
;
+
) -
$
"
@
"
"
;
#
#
"
+
*
"
*
"
"
"
B
*
#
3
#
%
"
"
@
"
"
!
;
"
;
;
(
) )
* "
$
"
/
=
*
@
"
"
!
#
C
@
*
@
D
/
#
"
"
/
@
#
@
- @
<
(
"
* "
"
( "
"
) , -
@
;
!
;
"
;
"
$
"
*
@
#
"
!
@
"
#
!
*# " @
"
"
@
@
"
#
@
@
*
@
-
*
=
3
7-*=3:
'
< %"
= 7)99&:
! "
#$
%
< D" J
? 0&
8
7)9&1: %
2
. <
( /
#
3
(
) 1
5 C 7)99 :
&
%'
&
-
=
/
7
.
:
$ $
D ')I,
< 7)99&: < ( C
* #
(
%
)
*
71:
< 3
< 7)99&:
% < D" J
?
< 8
* 7)99&:
% < D" J
?
< / 85 7)99': %
&
&
> ) ,
< D" J
?
< / 85 7)99': %
&
&
> , )
< D" J
?
< / 85 7)99': +
),-$
,- ,"
.)--"/ % "
,
< D"
J
?
8-3% 7)99 :
8 -
3
*
D
) 2 -
!
"
"
#
"
#
#
$
#
$
%
#
&
'
!
(
)*
Maximum A
Most likely B
Minimum C
Estimated range of costs (£m)
Actual
cost
Feasibility study
Design
Tender
Construction Claims
settlement
A
B
C A
B
C
Feasibility
study
Tender Settlement
A B C
+
), -
#
#
.
+ #
/
# #
.
0
#
1
#.
"
$
#
"
$
#
-
#
2
#/
#/
#/
" /
"
$
#
#
"
!
#
1
.!
3
3
-
)
#
"
1
. 1
. 45!
"
$
(
#
"
(
$
#
6
(
2
/
7
"
#
#
8
#
45
#
$
#
# "
$
9
(
(
#
#
(
(
(
6
(
# :
#
(
!
); -
#
#
$
#(
(
"
"
#
#
"
0
2
#/
9
/
"
/
#
1
#
.
"
#
#
#
#
7
#
#
2
/
/
/
/
/
#
:
2
/
#
3
3
-
)<
/
#
#
!
&
. #
4
#2
(
"
#
#
#
" #
#
$
$
.
$
( (
(
" 8
#
( #
9 "
2
.
/
"
(
/
"
/
/
6 "
"
/
) -
"
/
/
(
!
" /
/
$
#
#
#
2
/
&"
#
"
"
2
!
!
!
"
$
#
#
$
.
(
(
#
3
3
-
8
# 3
#
#
!
#
! =
0
<<*!
'
( >
7
-
0 96
?
3
?
?
3
5
?
@
0
3
4
!
?
3
-
@
3
?
#
4
:
!
+
8
-
7
8
#
-
?
-
7
$
#
'
$
!
#
'
8
-
$
#
'
?
-
% -
%! 3
$
#
1
.
"
(
$
1
.
A! 8
"
"
#
$
$
6
B! 7
1
#
.
#
#
1
.
9
#
1
. 1
. 1
#.
"
2
/
/
6#
6
/
#
1 .
3
3
-
A =
"
2
"
6
6(
/
1
.
/
/
/
/
/
"
=
"
2
"
!/
!/
6#
!/
"
#6
!
&
#
# "
2
#
/
/
/
/
#
#
/
#
#!
(
.
(
$
2
1
.
#
2
/
B -
#
:
$
#
#
8
#
(
1
.
#
#
(
"
!
#
#
%!
"
.
(
=
!
A! "
#
B!
"
3
3
-
*
#
#
# (
#
"
$
#
(
$
(
(
/ #
"
( "
!
(
#
$
" (
"
!
$
45
# $
#
"
# ! 1
(.
, -
:
C
#
1 .
#
#
"
"
!
#
#
0
>@
"
&
#
#
$
#
(
$
"
(
#
1 .
(
#
$
#
#
$
#
1
.
$
#
.
"
1 .
#
#
#
&
#
3
3
-
$
#
#
$
(
#
=
(
$
"
(
#
#
#
?
#
3
" ?
3
#
1# .
# 4
"
$
$
; -
#
0
:
#
#
#
$
"
(
(
(
#
" # !
$
# $
#
9
#
"
:
"
9
C
#
#
3
3
-
<
0
#
:
2
- D 3
E + # E 7
E -
E
#(
9
#
#(
#(
<)F
>
(
# 5
(
A)F
,)F
.
/ (
%)F
B)F
.
#
(
&
$
-
"
5
"
.
$
>@
#
(
#
7
(
!
%) -
(
:
(
(
#
(
9
"
:
>
(
#
45
(
(
(
#
$
(
;)F
3
(
3
3
-
%
%)F
#
#
#
(
(
.
#
#
(
:
3
(
$
$
:
(
#
$
(
(
3
#
3
#
#
"(
GAF
)*G F
#
#
,
A(
%% -
#
$!
:
.
#
$
$
"
"
#
#
(
(
#
(
#
"
$
(
$
#
$
/
0
#
7
#
7
#
3
3
-
%A
3
#
#
#
45
:
#
#
#
(
"
# $
#
#
1"
.
# "
:
(
#
% &
"
:
#(
"
#
"
#
0
F
.
>@
BF
*F
( #
(
$
%B -
0
2
/
/
/
#
A
:
3
<< !
% :
3
?
4 = -: '
-
8 +C <
(
.
"82
+
(
#
5 ?- : >@ !"#$$&
)
1 ;
@ ; A
@ !"#$%&
/
/
:
@/ !"##2&
; A
5; / : / !"##$& !
!
! "
# !#! $!
%
6 <
"8B
/
!
" #
"#
"
#
$
%
$%
&
!
'()
*
*
!
*
!
!
!
!
*
&
'++
!
'+++
,
"
#
'(- .
/
!
0
1
2' .
*
! !
3
!
1
24
*
!
!
!
5
$1
2(%
3
!
!
!
!
'(2
6
3
'7+ .
/
3
!
$1
27%
!
!
!
"8
9#
!
1
27
"
#
"
# *
"
#
"1
#
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
a
b
a
b
a c
d
e
c f
g
f
g
f
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
Days
Houses
Assumptions:
– hand-over every 5 days
– 2 foundation teams
(a-b)
– 3 structural teams
(c-e)
– 2 finishes teams
(f-g)
– duration: 75 days
(*) Initial durations set at
multiple of 5 days
Foundations Structure
Buffer
Finishes
75
:
'7'Close road
Temporary fencing
Break up and remove deck
Remove ballast
Scaffolding
Remove scaffold
Burn up and remove steel offsite
Lower steelwork to road
Excavate
Reduce wing
walls and abutments to
final levels
Remove temporary
fencing Reopen road
Clear site and
demobilise
Pier
reinstatement
A B C D
Bridge span
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Time in weeks
Final grading and shaping
1.
2.
3.
Reduce wing walls and abut to
final levels
Re-open road
Remove temporary fencing
'74 .
/
3
!
2'
$'% 6
$4% &
$(% * 1
';
9
$'% &
!
!
<
!
=
2'
<
3
'7( 6
>
!
?
@
+
+ A ; B ;
< 6 ;
C
< 6 C
< 6
!
6 ')
C
@ <
4
@
< 4
< ';
@
'(
>
(D
$4%
=
>
*
(D *
!
?
<
E
C
$% :
C
3
; F
< '+
6 '4
C 7 < 6
. - 6
1 '+ 6
0 '+ . C
@ 7 < $4 %
G ; . 1
> ' @ 0 G
'77 .
/
=
?
.
?
F6F.F0F>
$(% 1
( <
;
1
;
>
(-
4 8
!
F6F1FGF>
=
$'% *
" #
8
$4% *
!
$(% 6
?
$7% 6
E
"
#
$;% .
'7; !" "
*
?
<
8
"
#
"
#
"
#
1
*
*
*
*
!
!
"
# ,
*
8
!
" # *
#
"
/
!
'7D .
/
!
!
/
6
*
8
!
,
!
=
1
$ %&
!
!
!
*
,
!
'7)
!
@
*
/
:*E=H
:. /
*
$%
0
8
*
!
$
%
&
$8<&%
$,<&%
*
'+
222
!
,
!
!
&
'7- .
/
$
%
C
!
!
$
%
*
1
"
# $
%
# C
9 @
9 6
9
.5
!
!
" !#
6
/
/
6
!
*
#
5
.
3
'72
*
#
!
$ */%
!
1
!
*/
,
@/:
1
!
$.5 %
&
!
!
?
$0=*%
@
9 @
9 6
?
!
9 @
9
?
$
%
9 6 *
';+ .
/
9
$ !
%
*
"@
*#
*
&
!!
8
9 /
!
1
$
%
9 C
9 C
9
<
I
*
8
9 *
9 8
9 8
9
$ !
%9 ,
!
9
<
G/ 8
58 $'2-4%
(
8 :
6 6< 6
C1 /G $'2-)%
8 :
';'& @
. : 58 $'2-(%
8 :
'("
!" # $
!
!
E
!
$%
$ %
3 -4
1 <
&
1
< 6 C
3
.
7+ !
<
'4+ !
6
(+ !
1
)+ !
&
3
.
'4+ !
6
';+ !
<
';+ !
1
4;+ !
1 !
3
.
'2+ !
6
(++ !
<
(;+ !
1
;++ !
& 7 (
C
(+ !
6
47 ! (++!!
C
7+ !
';4 .
/ 5
' D+ !
5
;+ !
); !
1
4+ !
8
-+ ! ';+!!
: '++ !
!% &
!
'D
< -
<
6
'+
'(
4 ) '( '-
44
*
(!
8
((
(;
7+
'+++
$
'%
!
#
.
'+++
F
!
!
(++ );
(! 4
7
<
!
'!
!'
(
$% 6
C
';(.
'D
$ %
3
*
#
J;+ +++
9
C
$
%
'
#
( K
4 1 '- '
(
'4 4
7 :
'4 (
; &
7 (
D C * D (
) C ** 7 ;D
- 6
( ;D
2 & ( D
'+ /
7 2
'' 6
4 )-
'4 &
( 2
'( .
; '4
'7 /
'- '+
'; C *** 7 )'+
'D C *L 7 '(';
') /
4+ '(
'- 6
* D 7''';
'2 6
** '4 'D'-
4+ * D '7'D')'-
4'
( '24+
$
%
6
.
4+ J777 +++
.
< M ') 'D JD++ +++
/ 6 '- JD++ +++
/ C M '7 'D J)++ +++
';7 .
/ !)
=
1
2'
$'%
.
$4% <
$'%
!
;
$(% $'%
&
C
C
$ %
5
' & '
4 . D .
( .
7 .
7 .
7 .
; .
D .
D !
)
) 1
- 6
- 1
D 6
2 1
D 6
'+ 1
- 6
'' 6
2 6
'4 6
) 6
'( 6
) 6
'7 6
2 6
';
7 6
'D
7 6
')
7 6
'- 6
' 6
';;
!
"
#
#
#
"
$%&
#
#
#
"
#
#
#
'
(
)
!
$*&+
,
-
.
.
/
0 -
1
2
(2 $3$)
(45')
(607-)
(6071)
1
0
, 4
5
$%+
('071)
2 $38
-
(-5)
(6071 607-) '
(05)
(6071 '071) '
(
)
(6'0)
'
1
$%9 4 1
:
(-1 ) (6071/607-)$33 5
$33
(01 ) (6071/'071)$33 5
$33
!
-
;
'
;
-
<
12000
9600
7200
4800
2400
0
Time now
Cost
BCWS
BCWP
ACWP
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Time
-
1
0
, 4
5
$%*
"
- (
) -
-
=
-
!
2
:
'
'
-
.
-
!
(2 $3>)
"
$&3 4 1
:
#
#
#
#
(
)#
$
'
" #
:
0
110
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
55%
Manpower peak
Design progress
Approximate technical
manpower:
May vary by job (determined
by design co-ordination)
53%
42%
27%
15%
7%
3%
42%
30%
20%
10%
3%
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
Job duration (%)
Technical design manpower (%)
100
50
0
Design progress (%)
1
0
, 4
5
$&$
"
2 $3?
-
-
-
1
2
2
1
100
80
60
40
20
0
0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34
Time
Project cost (%)
Planned progress
" -
$&8 4 1
:
$ % &
2 $3%
"
7
$ 0
1
0
, 4
5
$&>
@
>
'
:
'
-
4
1
-
'
4
(45')
-
:
,- 0 4 45'
$&? 4 1
:
'
/
1
1
- -
<
(
)
$3$
!
-
( 1
:
,
4
>&3 333 ?+%3
'
8*% 333 ?*33
4
%33 333 &333
= ??3 333 &333
1
0
, 4
5
$&%
: 6;
>3A
!
!
) *
*
'
6071
'071
7
'
<
1
!
#
0
$&& 4 1
:
<
?3
>8
9
,
45'
45'
!
6
;
45'
'
+ ,! *
$38
4
2 $3&
-
$38 -
1
0
, 4
5
$&+<
45'
-
1
/
( 7
7
'
4
1
2
%%3 ?%3 398
. >333 8%33 39>
1
$%33 $+33 $$>
:
8>33 8833 3*&
4
*33 &33 3&&
0 >33 >33 $33
' -
$&9 4 1
:
0
-
?
?93
>
>83
- !
$%
?93
?
%3A
?
?93
'
'
!
**A
**A
**A
**A
**A
!
45'
6
1
0
, 4
5
$&*
0
:
,-
B :
45'
: 4
.
!
,-
2
,-
$
$ 833
(0C)
$8 -
$8
,- B
(,-B2)
833 333
8?3 333
$3> 0
!
3*&
*
( 4
/
:
4
'
1
$ $3 333 $9 333 3%%
8 ?3 333 %3 333 393
> &3 333 +3 333 39&
? %3 333 ?9 333 $3?
% ?3 333 >3 333 $>>
& 83 333 $% 333 $>>
+ $3 333 9 333 $8%
9 * 333 $3 333 3*3
* $ 333 8 333 3%3
8?3 333 8%$ 333 3*&
$+3 4 1
:
$>>
3%
45'
$+
$&
-
-
-
7
$&
'
>3 333
3>> 0
45'
'
>
-
0
$$ 333 333
<
!
1
0
, 4
5
$+$
"
#
#
#
#
#
;
"
#
#
#
7
- .!!
-
45'
'
45'
D
<1
-
4' ($**$)
0
4 =
$+8 4 1
:
:
@ ($***) !
"
8 2
1
E
= B ($**&) !
"
#
- E
F= ($**+)
!
"
: B
@ E
1
0
, 4
5
$+>
! "
"
"
#$%
&
'
!
!
(
"
"
!
"
(
" "
!
)*+,-
)-!. )-
'
/ "
"
0 0
1 #$2
3
"
(
"
!
!
"
4
"
"
3
"
(
.
56
#$7 1 4
(
&/'
)(
###-
)#-
/
0
0
0
'"
0
0
8
/
0 0
1 #$$)9- /
/
:
)
-
);-
/
(
/
"
0
<
)#- 4
<
& '
)9- +
#$= 1 4
>
&>
'
)(
##9-
"
"
"
<
1 ) * : #??;-
0 0
1 #$?
'
"
)
-
:
'
0
: @
: @
: @
<
@
:
@
:
@
#=A 1 4 : "
@
:
@
: )-
@
: )-
@
!
@
+
B
3
!
"
3
3
3
3
3
"
3
3
3
' 3
" 3
3
"3
3
3
3
"
3
!
1
(
0 0
1 #=#
"
(
##;
>
& " '
&
! " '
& C ' & '
" &
'
)
- "
B
! "
"
"
&
'
D
"
' )
"
-
#=9 1 4
0 0
1 #=;
"
1
)4
-
"
&
'
"
" !"
)
! "
"
" !"
- !
"
!"
! "
" !"
B
" !"
! "
"
"
"
!
D
5
! "
!
" '
#=% 1 4
! "
"
"
<
0
*
"
"
"
"
(
"
)
-
"
"
!
&'"
'
"
(
0 0
1 #=2 "
'"
'"
"
! "
! " 56
56
&
' 4
)
! "
"
-
)
-
!
)(
##%- +
(
+
"
(
"
#=7 1 4
+
0 0
1 #=$
"
(
"
B
3
3
3
"
1
"
"
B
!
'
3
!
3
!
3
3
3
3
#== 1 4 '
3
3
3
<
B
'
3
"
3
3
"3
3
3
"
!
!
:
!"!
!
#
D D D )*++-
"
"
#$
0 0
1 #=?$
#
!
56 +
!
'
!
! "
"
4
%
4
:
' '
1 '
"
"
! "
'
8
0
"
0
"
'
4
#?A 1 4
*
'
(
'
'
8
' "
"
"
4
B
3
)
!
-3
0 0
1 #?# "
3
&##
<
) -
) 1-
)
-
)1-
) 1 -
)1 - 1
1
1
"
B
&
'
3
"
56
&
' & '
#?9 1 4
&'
#$
0
(
" #$
/
!
0
0
'
0 0
1 #?;1
E
"
% &' '
&
"
' & ' &'
)*+,-
"
)
-
)
-
'
"
F
:
&
'
&
'
#?% 1 4
&' & '
0
+
1
"
3
1
'
&
"
'
&
'
! !
" B
"
3
3
3
3
'
B
3
"
3
!
F
"
0 0
1 #?2
<
(
)
&
' )*+,- &
'
1
,
!
"
: 56
&
'
&
'
:
#2G
! " B
"
3
3
3
3
! " B
#?7 1 4
"
3
3
3
"
"
"
'
"
"
'
) "
- 1
)&
'-
'
)&
'-
"
0
"
'
0
"
"
"
0 0
1 #?$
:
!
&"'
& ' (
"
&
'
) & '-
5
"
'
"
'
'
"
B
3
3
3
3
"
B
)
-3
3
3
'
"
' 5
#?= 1 4
"
"
"
) -
'
*
'
"
'
(
##2 2A!
2A
H#2A
2A!2A
H#2
H#;2
H#2$2
H#72
#AG #7$G
2AG
)%2G-
B
0 0
1 #??
"
B
3
3
3
3
3
'
9AA 1 4
0
B
" 3
"
"
(
##7
"
"
( )
& ' &
' *
&"
' "
* &
'
"
"
0 0
1 9A# 4
1
>
0
4
"
<
"
!
9A9 1 4
"
&
' +
"" .
3
!
8
!
"
B
!
&:
@'
!
)
- 8
@ 8
@ 8
0 0
1 9A;
@
3
1
"
0
"
<
B
&
'
&
'
(
"
"
56
) -
> #??;
*
" <
& ' &'
(
"
"
"
"
"
1
"
"
9A% 1 4 "
"
"
#
* >4F : 0< )#??;-
1 # * 1 4
<
*
1 )#?=$-
2 <
F
)#??2-
!" # 9
F
)#???- $
F
F 0 4 )#??%-
$%
&
%"
'
()
&
<40+ F
I/ 0 0I )9AAA- /
B $"
* E
;A 2$#D==
0 0
1 9A2
!
"
#
$
%
&
$
'
(
"
)
#
*(
)
!
$
#
#
+
!
#
,
-
"
+
#
#
#
#
+
+ .
+
"
/
+
+
0
1
#
#
"
2
#
-
2
-
2
2
2
+ $
-
2
)
.
$
.
3
*4
!
1
+
2
2
2
2
0
1
#
2
2
.
+
$
!
/$
+ /
-
+ 5
#
-
#
$
#
*6 5
$
0
$
#
7
!
,
#
$
!
!
$
3
$
$
$
$
)
)
/
+
$
$
#
!
$
+
!
#
.
7
,
-
#
#
#
!
$
7
.
3
*8
+
0
9
+
"
!
5
:
!
:
7
% !
#
)
!
!
$
1
-
;
$
1
2
#
* 5
$
0
#
$
!
#
#
:
#
$
$
$
#
1
#
2
#
2
"
2
+
2
"
!
#
"
$
+
$
+
!
"
)
#
'
!
#
#
"
.
3
5
<
$
!
=
-
<
5<
3
!
3
#
#
3
!
1
7 >
5<2
7 >2
2
$
2
2
2
2
2
9
"
/
+
!
!
9
#
+
#
)
!
$
!
5
$
0
!
= 88'
"# $ 0B , D
.
3
!
"
#
$
%
&&&
'
(
)
*
+
!
*
+
'
,
!
!
) "
-
.% &&/
0
1
1
2
'
*
%
345678
)
9 3456&8
(
-
2
$
(
,
+
:
&&; ) ' "
$
)
)
9 3456&8
!
9
%
3< 4/48
<
)
Bloggs
engineering
Marketing
sales
Electrical
engineering Architecture
Power Control Fabric
Lighting
Interiors HVAC
Mechanical
engineering Administration
Transportation Accounts Personnel
Pressure
<
) "
-
.% &&=
-
2
-
)
2
%
"
3< 4/&8
1
)
)
-
'
Mondo
engineering
Rail
engineering
Design Maintain
Construction
Water Administration
engineering
Design Maintain
Construction
Highway
engineering
Design Maintain
Construction
IT
-
&&7 ) ' 2
)
)
2
)
3< 4//8
)
9
2
2
Chief
Executive
Execution/
production
Design
department
Cost control
department
Members of design, production and cost control departments
who are working on projects A, B and C
Project A
Project B
Project C
'
) "
-
.% &&>
!
3455=8
+
?
3< 4/;8
Bloggs
engineering
Superdesign
architects
Structural
engineering
Structural
engineer
Prestige
design
Design
architect
Contractual agreement
Project contract
management
Project management
structure
Control systems
Communication
systems
! 0
&&6 ) '
!
%
+
:
3< 4/=8
+
"
) "
-
.% &&5
!
0
+
3455;8
!
!
)
@
&/A ) '
! # $
'
!
!
,
!
0
9
9
) "
-
.% &/4 )
2
,
" % &
"
)
!
'
"
!
-
&/& ) '
,
2
)
)
2
)
$
'
(
2
0
!
) "
-
.% &//
"
:
0
!
: 2
(
!
$
0
!
%
!
<
0
4= 47
)
$
0
&/; ) '
"
2
(
+
: B +
3+
455;8
+
C
$
$
$
2
)
2 ?
0
'
2
<
) "
-
.% &/=
2
)
0
2
?
* &&
2
C
$
$
$
2
$
$
+
*
%
B' 345678
&
#
+ 0* 3455;8
+
#
+
B 3455;8
!
"
#
+0
#
&/7 ) '
+ 3455=8
"
?
)
" D
)
E 9 , 3456&8
$# %
&
' ( + F , D
#
* ,' 3455/8 )
* "
< < 3457>8
%
'B + '
+ 0* 3455=8 (
)
!
+
#
+
-E 3455>8 $
&
)
) #
, 3455;8 *
!
+ *
% )
*
) "
-
.% &/>
!
"
#
$%&
'
"
(
#
)
*
+
"
,
-.- / / "
"
#
"
#
0
$%1
+
2
+
3-4
+
/ /
$.5
6
0
3$4
'
7
"
7
'
+
)
"
,
-.$
3-4
8
3$4
0
$.-
3%4
+
"
3.4
+
+
+
)
,
-.$ "
$.$
6
0
9
36(74
:
3'(74
3 4
7
3"(74
6(7 '(7
3 "(7 4
3;(74
6(7 6(7 '(7 ;(7
-1<5
-1&5
+
"
#
:
0
$.%
#
7
)
7
6
3 4
6
#
)
+
$..
6
0
3
4
6
7
3
4
;
+ #
+
,
-.%
0
$.=
"
"
#
#
+
7
3
4
;
9
3
4:
>
34
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
$.?
6
0
+
3 4
3
4
,
)
3
4 3
4 + +
3 4
+
@
3
4
3
4
"
+
3
+ A
4
0
$.<
"
#
#
#
"
+
7
+
#
3
4 )
3
4
+
#!!
!!
+
3
4
,
-..
,
-.=
)
$.&
6
0
0
$.1
3
4
7
*
A
7
A
#
7
0
+ 3 704
)
70
"
,
)
+
3,
-.?4
+
34
6
+
"
3
4
$=5
6
0
!
0
$=-
3
4
/
3
*"
4
;
;
+
9 )
B
+
)
+
;
3
4
@
;
$=$
6
0
34
"
+
*
*
-5 ;
"
6
*
3 4
6
3
4 +
3C, 4
# C,
C,
9
0
$=%
3
4:
3
4:
3
/
4:
3
4:
3
4
C,
3-4
:
3$4
+
3%4
" (B
#
+
C,
3,
-.<4
#
+
"
+
$=.
6
0
+
#
C, +
+
C,
!
# $
"
,
9
,
#
3
4
'
#
+
* 3
4
#
0
$==
#
3
4
#(
(
(
+
#@
0
) 3-1=.4
:
+
)
+
,
3
4
"
#
+
D #
6
+
)
3 4
+
0
3 + *
3
0
4 @
-11.4
$=?
6
0
" %
"
9
7
3 +
4
+
+
3
4 E
,
7
+
3
4
7
#
+
# 2
3
4
0
$=<
7 +
3
4
+
*
+
*
+
,
0
+
+
;
-1&1
$=&
6
0
8
>
6
>
7
6
@
7
0
D +
8
@
>
E
"
D
*
7
,
E
,
+
(
;
7!
*
+
6
/
3 -1&14
& '
"
,
,
!
0
$=1
"
9
7
#
+
+
7
#
;
3
4
7
#
!
3
# +
4 )
#
3
#
4
+
!
3-4
#
$?5
6
0
3$4
3%4
:
3.4
#
!
,
!
!
3
4
"
!
/
(
9
:
:
#
<=F 15F
;
+
3 ,04
@
,
-.%
0
$?-
A
,0
+
" ,0
+
,0
+
,0
3
4
,0
,0
,
+
+
)
+
,0
"
3 ,"4 "
#
*
+
$?$
6
0
,0 E
,"
,0 *
,0
," ,0
3
+ 4
*
+
+
+
3-1&14
!
"#
$ %
" G 3-11<4 &
! !
$ &
'(
)
"
6
;+
*
@ 3-11=4
!
! &
*
)
' *
) 3-11<4 "
'(
*
"
)
' H I
) " 3$55-4 ) '(
*
D
D ( 3-11<4
% "
6
EG
@
A 3-11<4 )
,
6
H I
0
$?%
!
"
#
$
%#$&
#$
'()
%*+,& ,
,
-
,
*
*
+
$
.
.
,
/
,
#
0
#
'(1
+
.
+
,
*
*
'(( 2
*
#
+
313
$
$
$
2
$
4
5
5
5
#
6
+
+
3
3
7
'
,
'
0
#
'(8
4
3998 +
1: 31;
'(< 2
*
#
:
!
%3998&
#
5
-
$
0#
-
4
%3&
5
%'&
5
%:& 5
%)&
5
%1&
5
0#
0
,
%3& +
0
#
'(9%'& +
%:& =
%)& 0
" # !
.
%3& "
%'&
%:& "
"
6
6
0
2
%)&
'8; 2
*
#
$
%
& +
31'
31>
<1>
-
Influence on total construction costs (%)
65% 25% 10%
5% 10% 85%
Appraisal and
project definition
Design and
contracts
Construction and
procurement
Client and
specialist
consultants
Design team
Contractors and suppliers
Actual expenditure during each stage (%)
"
4
3999 +
)<
0
#
'83
,
$
-
2
,
/
.
%
&
2
?
7 7
"
?
*
*
'8' 2
*
#
*
@
*
"
%
&
0
#
'8:
!
0#
0
%3999&
4
5
5
2
#$
0#
0
%3999&
4
5
5
5
-
0
$
2 .
#$ 6""
=
A
0#
0
%3999&
4
5
5
5
'8) 2
*
#
313
$ %
B
%3999&
+
31:
$
%3999&
%+
31)&
4
5
5
+
+
311
0
#
'81 & *
*
*
*
@
=
@
=
0#
0
4
0
4
0
4
0
4
0
4
0
4
0
4
0
4
A
C" C" C"
0 C" C" C"
*
C" C" C"
*
C" C" C"
!
5 C"
5
'8( 2
*
#
' %
*
2
0
.
+
31(
!
*
A
C
Project value chain
Feasibility
value
Corporate
value
Business
value
Design
value
Construction
value
Commission
value
Operational
value
4
3999 +
<3;
0
#
'88Information
Human resources
Procurement
Development
Organisation
Brief Generation Evaluation Communication
Designer (consultant)
Information
Human resources
Procurement
Development
Organisation
Estimate
tender Construction Commissioning Operating
Contractor
Information
Human resources
Procurement
Development
Organisation
Operate Maintenance Renewal Transfer
Operator
Information
Human resources
Procurement
Development
Organisation
Corporate Business Project Asset
Client
Information
Human resources
Procurement
Development
Organisation
Corporate Business Project Asset
Client
Promoter value system - (Strategic) Multi-value system - (Tactical)
Decision to consult
User value system - (Operational)
"
%
*
&
4
3999 +
<3
'8< 2
*
#
Promoter value system Multi value system User value
system
Promoter's
value chain
Financier/
banker's
value chain
Internal
stakeholder's
value chain
Promoter's
value system
Contractor's
value system
Designer's
value system
Regulatory
authorities'
value system
User
value chain
Contractor's
value chain
Regulatory
authorities
value chain
Project value chain
Corporate
value
Business
value
Project
value
Design
value
Construction
value
Commission
value
Operational
value
Customer's
value chain
External
stakeholder's
value chain
Regulatory
authorities'
value chain
Specialist
contractor's
value system
Project
manager's
value system
Supplier's
value system
Quantity
surveyor's
value system
Customer's
value chain
Promoter's
value chain
Financier/
banker's
value chain
4
3999 +
<33
0
#
'89Promoter value system – strategic phase Multi-value system – tactical phase User value system –
operational phase
Project value chain
Corporate
value
Business
value
Feasibility
value
Design
value
Construction
value
Commissioning
value
Operational
value
Promoter
value system
Promoter
value system
Promoter
value system
Promoter
value system
Promoter
value system
Promoter/
designer
value system
Promoter/
designer
value system
Promoter/
designer
value system
Promoter/
designer
value system
Promoter/
designer
value system
PFI
Consortium value system
Turnkey procurement
Contractor/designer value system
Design and construct
contractor led design
Contractor/designer value system
Traditional procurement
Contractor value system
Designer value system
Consortium value
system
Operational
client user
value system
Operational
client user
value system
Operational
client user
value system
Operational
client user
value system
Design and construct
client led design
Contractor/designer value system
$
4
3999 +
)8
'<; 2
*
#
*+,
,
-
?
,
(
#$
3 "
';;;
2
D
= D
2
$
2 .
%$2.& #
$
0
#
'<3
*+,
E
3998
';;; ,
$
2
D
%$2D& $2.
#$
4
%3&
5
%'&
5
%:&
A@
.
$2.
,
!
#
F
%!#F& " 0
E
=
0
6
"
0
0
6
*
F
0
#$ G'
9;>
G3;;7';;
'<' 2
*
#
*
,
+
318
4
1
3;
:
6
A
"
A
+
%,*&
,*
A
+
4
5
5
5
!
%A*2&
#$ 0 *
0
#
'<: ' *
4 -
3999
'<) 2
*
#
) ! !
,
2
*+,
6
%';;;&
"
A@
=
2
#),
0
6 *
*
?
A@
D
C
*+,
*
*+,
0
#
'<1
#"02
A
,
,?0"$
*+,
#"02
.
,
A
*
<;>
"
';>
6
6
0
'<( 2
*
#
A
"
#
,
"
A
,
*
0
#
'<8
,
,
#
( 2
'<< 2
*
#
,
,
,
$
+
31<
+!
6
$ ! * F
D
# * %';;;& %
$ &
'
+
D
$2D
(
) $
(
*
E 3999 '71)3
- D C
$
# %3999& '
'
+
(
,
2
D
#
3
4??
?
?
?
# %3998&
(
$
'
+
*
*
=
C %3999& ,
-
(
*$
A
=
"
E %399<& (
#
(
.
/
*$ 0
A
0
# %399<&
(
$
!
0
(
#
'
+
*
*
=
(
) $
(
*
D
C 33 38
# :
2
E %399<& +
-
0
1 0
(
$2D *
D
F
E=
!
$! %399(& $
(
! /
#
6
6
0
#
'<9
!" #
$
%&
' ()** +
,-
#
,-
&
.
&
/*!
'
.
.
(
+
.
.
,
.
0
1
1
2
2
2
.
3 # &
/*)
0
' 1
1
1
1
1
%
'
1
1
1
4
&
2
0
1
1
1
(
+
5
4
6
/*/ 7
$
8
&
9
0
'
(3
:
)**;+
,# 4
&
7
()**)+
0
<
&
9
()**=+
0
4
'
'
7
.
4
4 >
&
4
()**)+
0
'
7
8
(7
)**?+ 0
3 # &
/*@
4
7
8
9
3
.
%
'
%
'
6
A
2
9
)=)
%
'
%
'
4
4
/* 7
$
:
B
'
B
3
#
0 7& )**C
3 # &
/*;
.
.
7
%'
%
<
'
9
)=/
'
.
.
$
1
.
/*= 7
$
&
#
0 &
(&+ )**;
3 # &
/*C !"
-
'
.
.
/ B
#
&
.
4
(4B8+
$
.
4
D
/*? 7
$
.
9
#
7
&
(7&+
4
4
4
4
&
&
.
2
%
'
B
1
9
E
5
3 # &
/**
9
# $
2
2
2
2
2
E
%
'
&
% %
#
.
@!! 7
$
0
1
1
1
1
1
.
1
1
$
F
$
,# 4
&
7
()**)+
0
1
' 1
1
1
1
1
'
1
1
1
1
1
8
&
9
(3
: )**;+
/<)!"
@!"
,-
#
3 # &
@!)
'
.
#
%
'
7.
'
4
9
'
'
7
3
<
<
.
4
3
.
2
@!/ 7
$
2
4
4
8
'
B
&
&
%2
<
'
@!"
8 $ -
(.
$
)**/+
%
3 # &
@!@%%
'' <
4
1
4
'
$
()**/+
%
'
%
'
,
4
.
.
3
()**@+
%
'
,
.
.
5
7
&
8
,-
@! 7
$
0
1
1
1
1
1
5
%
<
'
'
,
2
%
<
'
.
0
(%
4>& ()**)+
4 >
&
4
2
B&
3
8 ()**@+ 3
<5
D
3
:
: # ()**;+
!
"
&
#
#
&
,
8
8
& ()**;+ #
$
3 # &
@!;%
& &
B
8
8
8
#
E /@<) 4
G
& ()**=+ '
()
&
9
8
#
E )!/<) 4
G
7& ()**C+
7
&
7
#
:
()**?+
8
B
7
5$#D
$
& $ B
# $ ()**/+
0
<
'
*
)*+++()+ )?
)/
&3 ()**?+
!
&
3
066
6
& ()**;+ %
&
# 8
)**; & &
4
G
5$
()**?+ &
,
>
E -
,
.
%
5$#D
#
$ ()** +
9
8
>
6
8
&
4
,- &
5$#D
@!= 7
$
!
"
#
#
"
$
% & '
(%
)
*+,-
*+.-
/
0-,
(
(
*+.-
# "
1
&
2
3
2
3
&
4
!
5
#
$
#
5
6
7
$ 1
$
$
%
)
1
0-. 8
"
1
4
9
(
6
*,* #
(
*!
"
#
#
#
%'4!
:!
"
&
"
6
" "
"
0-+
*!
%
(
:!
(
#
(#
# (
(#
0!
7
#
#
/
#
;!
!
'
'
#
#
0*- 8
"
1 !
#
#
(
4
9
9
!
9
#
3
3!
4
' 6/
(7 #
#
/
4
(
?
% 8/
1
9
/
9
9
"
!
'
"
6
" "
"
0**
#
4 >-@
(
8
4
9
4
#
9
1
(
#
4
#
4
9
#
9
9
(
9
9
4
"
$
)
3 (
5
0*: 8
"
1
A
A
9
'
#
9
= 9
/
#
#
'
(
B
% "
"
'
*-
/
1 C
% "
0<
/
(
%
(
/
4
/
*- <<
'
*- *<
9
$
"
6
" "
"
0*0/ :-
"
5
#
#
A
(
/
3
#
$%
/
9
9
=
/
/
/
"
# /
%
B
/
"
4
/
0*; 8
"
1
4
/
%D*>
?
%
8/
1
/
$
/ (
9
/
4 /
# # 8/
A
9
/
&
'
#
#
#
#
(
4
9
/
4
9
/
9
#
4
/
(
9
4
4
"
6
" "
"
0*<
9
3
9
3
9
#
(
#
9
3
#
# (
#
(
#
#
#
# (
#
(
#
# (
(
#
#
9
#
0*> 8
"
1 '
'
/
(
$
#
"
/
/
&
9
B
#
(
4
%D<--
9
9
9
B
(
#
(
( ) * !
#
#
#
"
6
" "
"
0*, *! 8
#
:! E
#
1
#
(
#
#
5
(
#A
(
#
#
"
/
#
5
A
/
A
)#
#
)#
#
#
9(
# (
#
(
5
#
#
A
#
#
/
A
0*. 8
"
1
#
#
A
/
#
#
/
A
#
#
9
#A
#
A
#
#
#
#
A
#
#
#
$
#
(#
(
#
(#
6
(#
#
#
#
*
4
9
#
#
(
/
(
5
A
/
A
(# A
"
6
" "
"
0*+
#
9
#
'
#
*!
#
(
(
:!
(#
0!
9
(
;!
(
#
(
(
# B
#
#
#
#
#
#
0:- 8
"
1 +
4
5
A
A
A
A
3
A
A
A
A
A
(
9
(
#
4
( (
/
#
4
( (
#
#
/
*!
:!
9
#
0!
3
;!
(
"
6
" "
"
0:*
#
!
#
*!
/
#
:!
(
#
0!
9
(
#
4
4
8 ' (
#
/
9
#
#
(
(
#
0:: 8
"
1 ,
"6!
'
*+.,
(
5
%
'
$
%#
1
1
#
7
' 4
4
'
6
%4
#
1
(
#
(
%4
#
/
4
8
6
%
%
"
8
A
4
, ! -
&
4 /
%
"6
3 /
3
#A "6
(8
(
#
(
"6(
8
/
"
6
" "
"
0:0
1
B
1
8
3
(
9
"% )!
"6
"6
2
3 B
/
/
E
9
/
4
8
F
'
(
#
E
9
6
/
0:; 8
"
1 "
./
4
"
6 "
;,
"6
$
B
*++,
4 # ( "6
9
'
(
9
9
"6
$
$'16!
/
B
1 3
"
B1"! $
C
)
"
2 3
/
4
(
E
;
/
/
/ # B
1 3 "
%
B1"%!
/
"6
2
3
%
C# '
6(
/
#
#
3
"6
6&#
"
6
" "
"
0:<
(
7
E
3
(
$
B1"% 6&(
#
#
/
(
7
G:<-
3 "6
7
#
(
(
4
/
(
%
"6
G<
8/ #
4
E
*-(
#
/ $1 *< ---
?"H! $1 :.>-
*-
*-@
# 0 !
/ 8
"6
6
*+++!
(
(
"6
(
5
#
A
#
A
0:> 8
"
1
#
A
A
2
/
3
B
"6
#
/
(
# /
"6
#
5
A
A
/
"6
1
/
9
#
(
"
5
#
A
"
6
" "
"
0:,
'
(
5
(
A
/
/
A
#
A
/
5
A
A
(
A
9
A
4
.<
)
/
9
(
"6
9
/
4
%
"6"! / 5
0:. 8
"
1
(
A
A
'
"6"
5
9
A
A
A
A
9
A
A
9
/
6
/
1 "6
/
9
&
6
*,: 8
"
6
" "
"
0:+#
#
#
(
#
4
#
)#
#
#
# 6
# (
#
#
#
#(
/
#
9
#
/
9
4
4
% C
9
9
/
E
#
/
#
9
9
9
/
4 /
/ '
"
00- 8
"
1
2
(
3
/
/
< *-
#
E
4
/
/ #(
/
/
4
(
# :
0
<
,
#
(
#
#
4
#
9
A
/
*:
*-(
9
6
#
/ 1* H
)
B
? # B
? & #
;-@
B
6
%
(
,<@
+-@
)
6
% *+++! "
# 1 #
"
6
" "
"
00*
1
4
% ?I *++>! $
H : *
4 7 J "
B
1
4
E *++.! % "
4 7 J "
B
% ?I
1
4 *++,!
&
'
0!
00: 8
"
1
!
!
"
#
$
" %
&
'
( )
* + #
&
&
$
)
)
,
)
-' +
"
+
&
$
.
/
0
#
1
2
0
)
/
&
&
$
)
0
345 46
#
0
7 + #
&
#
8
9
5
!"
$
'
.
2
$
-:
'
$
$
)
)
;
0
#
<
# $!
+-
0
+-
;
-:
+-
'
=
>
?
+-
+-
#
@
.
- -:
+-
% + #
&
+-
!
+-
2
-:
8
!
"
!
1576
-.A314 444
0
. +
&
BC%7
BCC3
!
.
+
&
+
,
8
!
-
+
+-
9
+-
%
&
#
-:
-:
+-
0
#
C+
-: "
)
0
)
D
(
)
)
!
'
& .# .
;: >BCCB?
E
58
.
'D 9 .8 >BCC ?
+
"
$44 F*
.
D; >BCC3?
&2 8 &
*4 + #
&
!
" !
#
$
%&'
( )
!
*
+
, !
-
.
%/
(
#
0
) 1
2
3456
'6
345'
3 6/7
!
&8 ,
2
0
!
!
0
9/ 686/
:
. 68/8
'8 0
2
0 ';;&
<
686/
&
+
%&6 *
*
=
>
#
!
!
*
0
>
0
!
!
*
# %&%
>
!
!
(1?,)
*
0
@
0
>
!
<
2
2
>
*
0
%&& *
?
3
4
#
!
!
0
987
!
.
*
# %&/
0
-
.
A
2
A
2
,
! "
"
0
-
. >
. (> .) >
. (> .)
. @
(.@ )
3B2 0
( 0 )
>
A
2
=
!
!
#
C
%&D *
!
-
.
# $
-
>
0
"
4
(';:%)
C
-
E'
E'888
> !
E'
E'888
C
!
'8+'/
C
'88
E'888
4
+ E'88
(
) +
-
0
!
!
(E'
) >
!
(E'888
)
*
# %&:
! !
4
! >
!
?
" ';' 0
!
4
!
!
+
!
;87
!
!
B
!
-
,
!
+
Hinge
Catch
" 0
!
%&9 *
<
!
- A
2
A
2 A
2
% &' (
,
!
-
!
0 ';:8
2
@
!
0
C
!
!
-
0
*
# %&;0
?
.
+
=
0
!
+ !
! .
4
"
!
>
!
"
"
%/8 *
$
0
0
0
0
)
0
"
A
2 A
2
!
!
"
0
*
# %/'
!
*
-
!
C
>
!
C
.
0
!
C
F
%/6 *
!
G
F
H
0
+
I F
#
>
!
3
+
>
#
*
# %/%
0
0
+
0
0
A 2
4
-
.
'87
987 !
3
0
-
. ,
#
(,# ) 3
1
0 "
# ("0 0#)
-
.
"0 0#
("0 0# ';;D)
!
$
()
G
()
2
<
%/& *
0
"0 0#
A2
!
1 "0 0#
0 ';;%
0
,
2
>
!
-
C
-
4
" (';:%)
.
. =
"
# = (';9&)
!
" # #
-
.
* 6%
#J K " 4 (';;;) $ & L
0
*
# %//# .
-
. (';9%) %
&
,!
3 * ,!
"0 0# (';;D) &
$GG
G G
0 # (';9') !
# &
=
4 0 (';;')
#' !
'
# 0
*
=
0 $GG
G
34>0 !
(
$GG
G
G
G
-
. (';9&) &
#
"
&
-
.
-
. (';;6) (
"
)
*++, "
,!
3 * ,!
-
. (';;&) (
"
)
*++-
"
,!
3 * ,!
-
. "
$GG
G
G
-
@
0 (';;&) (
) *++- +. ,!
3
* ,!
%/D *
!"#
$
%
&
' (
%
&
' )
* (
%
&
$
'
+
(
(
,-"
(
.
.
(
.
(
(
(
(
/
(
(
0
'
,-1 2
%
&
)3*
.
)4*
(
(
&
5
(
'
),*
(
(
(
'
)6* 2
$
$
7
(
7
2
%
&
,-#)-* $
8
' %
9
(
) * 2
&
:
(
(
.
$
;
(
'
.
)"* $
(
.
(
(
)1*
:
)#* /
, ! 2
%
&
)3!*
%
(
'
'
)33*
(
$
.
%
<
.
(
'
)34* %
.
%
(
(
&
)3,*
2
'
)36* =
7
2
%
&
, 3
%
/
(
.
)3-*
.
%
>
%
(
(
&
!
.
%
.
$
.
.
(
%
, 4 2
%
&
'
(
.
(
(
.
(
(
%
'
?
(
7
2
%
&
, ,
!
"
#$
%
&
'
!
$(
$)
)*
$+
$,
$)
)+
)*
$)
-%
+
.(+ /
&
#
0
1 2 .(,
.(( #
0
1 2
(, 3
4
! .+
!
.+
5
" #)
6
$ *
) 2
.
$)
+ $(
.** 77
-, 7
7
$*
$.
) $%
$.
-
))
6
$*** 7 8
9
:;
" #.
#
0
1 2 .(- 6
& 5
.(% #
0
1 2
& <
:
;
#
0
1 2 .(2
=
-,
$5)5.5(525$)5$.5
$(5)*5)$
&
4
" #.
&
:
;'
:
;'
'
'
$(
%
'
)
:;
1
> !
1
!
>
? $+
>
$-
!
8
-$
1
& $5)5.5(525
$)5$.5$(5)*5)$
$5)5.5(525$*5$+5)*5)$
!
@$,( ***
:-,5-$;
+ @,* *** A @)** ***
@++ ***
!
$-
$+
?
$+
'
1
!
1
.-* #
0
1 2 !
:;
B 9
B
9
B
9
B
9
B
9 B"
9
B1
9 /
$% B 9
/
<
.*
(
:;
,
:; /
)2
:;
<
0
=
B
9
+(
?
,*
#
0
1 2 .-$
!"# $%
&'(%
))
**
$
)+
*+ **(%
,- )'
.
*%(&
.
*+
)$
*&
.
)
/0# )*
(
.( #
)*&
1
)&*
"2 -
"-# )
* $ *$%
%
3 &
#
*
. *&
' ''(%
)($
3
/4#
.
+ ' &'
/ 5 )$'
. )+
6
5
)'
.
)$$
/
0 *+
*$($
/. 0
2
*
+(
3
$
/ !"# $%
. / !0# $%
(
( /77# 2 *+%
( 8
(
/7 # 2 *+
(
( (
/77 # 2
& *+%
&&
&' )+*
))) ))*
. )+
/"9#
3
$$(%
0 $%
.
*$
&+
.
($ $('
*'
.
2 %( &() * *)*
.
)$(&
*%) :;
'&(%+
2
'(&
& &' &% )+*
. )**(
)**(
*& +(* *' *&
,-
)'
)
2
)%
))
. *($
*$()
)+' )+& ) **
.
2 **$
. 8 2 **%
(&
)
,- )*(
*
& *+%(
*+
*)()
*$('
*)+
*+
*+
*))
8
2 *'
< *)*
<
*($
&&
*)+
8
2 *$('
*)(* *$
8
*'
2 *)
*)+
*+&(+
*&()+
*(*
2
*%
*)+
. *' *%(&
*) *$
**(
) *+
;
;
;;#
)&*
)
.
8
%&
8
)+( **&
)%(
))(*
2 *'
%%(&
)+(+
)+&(+
)+
)+
%($
%$(% *'+('
)+%(
. )+
)+%(
)%%
3
)
%&(+ )+ *'
%
)('
&*
)&&(*++
&()+
2
'(&*
=
=
= 3
8
=
)$('
*
2 * *'+
*$*($
+%
2
2 +
+)
(
/ #
%$('
2
*$ *%(
''(%
)$*
;
< *%*
$%
+$()'
. 2
. )(*
.
)*(
)()
.
3 )(&
< ";# $&
'()
.
)
%' &%(&
&
. ) $ '
&
2 **$
. 8 2 **%(
&&
)*(
,# $
3 $+($)
3
+
+
<.
# &$ &%
# &*
)*&
.
)*$('
<.
+) *&
> / 8
&(& *) **(
*$ *)*
&$
&+(& &*(' *+
&)(*
&*
.
3 '
*
)
,-
)%
. *
>
%
# ) )$+
< >0-# .
3 )$+
. '&
> # )')(*
)$%(&
3
*$
)$&('
)$$(%
)*('*
)*(%
>-# )'()
)*&(
# ' )()
)
(&
)$('
. )
))
,- )'
.
*%(&
*()
*$()
* *%
*$('
* *'(%
** *&($
83
8
**
. *)(*
*($
2
*($'
*
*'
&)(*
)
8
))'(%
))(*
3 &($+
)%()+
. . 2
'()
:, # $%
''(%
< '%(%)
3
%)
*% ;
<.
3 '('
.
$&('
.
8
%%
:
9 ) )&*(
2 )
2 )*)*
( (
:" #
&)
( (
(
:"; #
&)
:
: #
' )+
.
)%(&
)(&
)&
)
%$(+
(
%$('
. %'(+
$('+
%
%*(
' '%(
:; # '+(')
' ''(%
' '%(
'*(
:;
'&(%*
2 .. :;
'*
2 .. :;
'*(
'+(' '$('
'+ ')
:;0# '+ '(&
8 *+ **
'*(
+(
:-0# +(
.
. *(
)(*
()
3
< %
*&
%'
%'
<
%'
%'
3
)+*
3
% & &'(% *+ **+
'
+&(
* )($
.
3 )(&
; )*(
2 &()
:?
**(&
:
/
9
>
:/9># &% *'
:
8?
>8
'*(
)) *)'( **&
:
;
/
:;/# &% &
.
3 *%(
<
< )
<
3 $()
<
2
)*()
2 )*'
. )&(&
.
3 $('
$
)+
)()
,- )$
$(' *+ *$
)%
2 &% * *'(%
%(
+)
&()
&(&
+)
*& ++
2 '(+
&(&
<
&(' **$
# (*
$('
#
;
< *%$
2 .
# )$+
% &
))$('
2 '
1
. *& )$+
)
6@@5 )
. )
)
. *($
**
1
*+ **
.
:?# **&
.
'*(
. .
)$'
. . "; 2 *)$
A .
$ )&
.
.
8
%(&
. .
))*
. *)$
6. 3 5 )$* )$($
.
.
8
%
. <
))(&
*&
)'
)+
,- )'
&$ &&
)& )&'
2
*$
**$
***(+
. '+('
.
; #
)*(
2 &(& *) **(
*$(' *%
2 $% *+)
**&(+
)'
;
:
; :#
'
)+
)%
+*
2 ;" #
)*
&($
&($
)$&('
.
*%(
2 )*
;
:
;>; # . *$($
;
"2 -
*$%
2
*'
)*('
% **
*$
)%
*)(* *$
;07
3
$
8
)&'
2
&
2
*$)(*
.
)%*
** *&($
2 **'(%
**'
**' **%
B . 9 ) )&+
. )*)
)$$(%
*&
'*(
)) *)'(
**(&
B < %)
.
)%*
*%' ;
<
&()+
2 ($ *+
B/# . *&
*+
&$('
&*(% *'(%
&($
. &*
&$
. "; 2 *)'
( *&
%' &('
)*
)'%
.
'
&+(&)
&+(& &()
&
'&(%+
*)(* +)
2 *'
+ +) *&
'
< .
:;
%)(*
3
< %*
< %)
<
))%(
&
<
% )
.
. )+
- /
@ ''
@@
& &$
-
>
->#
2 )
. )' )()
)+(
:?
**&
)+*(
%'(+
2
$%
'$ ''(%
%*(
&
. :;
%()
2 ***(
2
***(
)$$('
*)%(
**
*& )(
.
$
< *
. :;
%+(%
))&(*+
C.(0. :< - # * *$
2 &( +()
.
%' &) **%(
*+
%+
*)% **
.
3
(&
*&
*+
)*(
&
*
7/0#
)*
)))(*%
. )**(
*+&(+
'(&*
.
.
)*)(*
8<
2 )*()
2 )*('
.
8
)'$('
)'&(%+
)))(*
))*($
))$(*
))
< )$+
"; *)(&
. +& )+
)$)
;
< *%%
:;
%+
2
'
&% * *'
7@ *+
(&
(&
&
"
.
)'
2 )'
)&+ )&)('
*++(*
. .
.
)&
*+*($
*+ *+)
)&*(
.
. )&(*++
)&'
)& )&'
)&' *+*
. *++
2 )&$('
2 )&
)&($
. )&(&
. )&) )&&
. )**( *+*(
&&D
'&
. )
. )'(%
*%($
)+(+
)$+
)(*
< 3
$($
2
*% ') *'+
.
'(%
*+
*& *&
. *)(*
2 )%
0 -
.
3 )%
2 ** *)*
*& )(
)
' '%(
*
,- )($
. &'
&
3
# )
<
.
8
%%(
$
+% )+
+&
&'
. ) $('
&'
)*
. )%(
)( )$
)*
"
: ;
/ 2 *
*+&
*)$('
";# )$ *)*(&
*)
*)'(
< *)* *)$('
. . 2 *)$
. *)'
2 *)
*)*
*)(&
*)$('
*)*(
?E *)$('
"
"
""#
*)(&
2 **'(%
.
)%)
*)) **&
)$*
2
. %'
&
)()
2 )%
0 -
.
3 )%
*% ;
<
" #
&)
(
(
"; #
&)
.
)&
*(*
:? >8
)) *)'( **&
-
>
5 . )' )()
*)%( **
*)% **
2 .
)%% )
*)% **
"/0# )*
$ )$'
8 $ '$
< '&
)%%
)$'
+&
*(&
'$
2 *+ **(%
2
$'(% ')
2
*%(
2 <
":"# ))(* **
2
'(+
+)
(&
2
. .
'()
2
'(%
2
$% *+(*)
2 ($ *+
)%(
.
**(
2
*($
*')(*
*$&(')
"2 -
;
"-;# ) * *$%
2
)
<
))%
))&(*+
$'(% )$ *$ *$&
2
2 & +()
2
'(&*
2
&
2 %(&
2
)& *+
2
($
2 ) )*)(*
)**
*+
2
+
. )%($$
2 .
)%$
)%$
)%$
)%% )
)%$
)
*+&(+
)$%(
2 + *) *$&
*$
. *)&(*
'$('
2 **' **%
*+($
.
)%)
.
)'$('
)'$
.
3 ($%
($
2
2 +
3
4 # $ *'()
3 &
3 $)(*
3
4 # $
3
4># )$*($
3
&
3
$*
3 %
3
3
3 $+($)
3 '(&
)$*
&($+
3
8
&'(%
. ) $ '
. &'
;
< *%&
)*
&'(%
3
+
3
. %+
9
)&* *+
%*
.
%%
$
)
.
'
.
3 (&
$('
(&
.
'
*)% **
*& +
*&(* %
&*(
**
*' *%(&
%
)$)
*& *
*& *
8
) +*
2 *'(%
2 %(& *& ++(* +( %
*&
=
<.
=
=
=
= =
=
= =
&$
.
*
%
0 $&('+ ' '$
<
2
3
*)(*
. %+
(.
. %+
.
< 0";# $&
. &'
.
0,# $
.
)$+
.
,- )$
'+(' '$(' %*
'+ ')
)'(%
. )(&
&$
*)% ** *'
&+
0
*)*
. .
*+
0
:
- **&
*+
*
**
%(
&
)*(
% $
&($+
2
8
%($
.
(&
$+
*) *$
.
)% *$
.
*(
2 **(
. )%(*'
*($
<
*)
*)
)&(*
*)(*
2 +
. **
)%(
)(&
*+ ;
<
.
**
) ))
)+(
*
)&($ *+)
2
*'+
.
)$('
)+($
2
($ *$&
.
0 -# )'(&
)%)($
)%(
)$(%
)'&(%+
)''
.
)''(&
.
)&()
*+
:;
%+(%
&&()+
)++(
< &&
)+
< . **+(*
)&()
)&)
.
)*' *)) *$)(*
)%()+
)
)%(
)&()+
)&
))+
<
)(&
)%
)%
)
)&
)'
)($
)'
))
)%()+
))
)*(
)$
)%
)%
3 ))
)+'
)$()
.
# &)(*
2
2 +
)*(
+
$
2 *$('
*' *% *)* **
.
)*)
. )+
3
4-# $ $*($
$($
$$(%
2
3 $+
;
*$$
2 &(& * *)
**( *$(' *)*
.
8
%&
9 *
(&
)
*$*
)+' )
)(*
. '
2 *'(%
3 2 )%
0 -
.
3 )%
'(
2 )
?0 :
)&*
*+)
?0 :
"
:" #
:
4 '$
?0 1 ?01# %+
. :;
%()
;
< *
, # %
.
)%$
2 .
,:# %
,-# '()&
'
)) )
.
)
'()+
)+
))(*
)+())
)*(%
.
3 )%
.
)()
,"# %
,9# %
'*
'*(
<
0
$(&
)*+(*
)'
(
. )&' *+* *+$
!/0# )*
'*(
&
))
%
'+ '*
. 3 *'
.
)&(&
! /
*) *' *$
)%+(%
)%()
*) ;
<